{"name":"Edvido Agency Index: Digital marketing agencies in Melbourne","paidPlansExcluded":0,"description":"Open-methodology scores (0-100) from publicly verifiable signals. Not a measure of the quality of work; positions are not for sale; Edvido membership does not affect scores. Unverified items score 0 and are not negative findings.","methodology":"https://www.edvido.com/agency-index/methodology","page":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne","language":"en","license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","generatedAt":"2026-10-14","methodVersion":"0.1-pilot","weights":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15}],"agencies":[{"rank":1,"name":"eMarket Experts","score":67,"website":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s6","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/about-us/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/crafting-ai-ready-content-that-demonstrates-google-eeat/","supports":"Pricing page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/seo-tools-for-the-ai-era-whats-working-in-2025/","supports":"Portfolio page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/case-studies/","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s6","url":"https://www.emarketexperts.com.au/services/","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#emarket-experts"},{"rank":2,"name":"Spicy Web","score":63,"website":"https://spicyweb.com.au/","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":16},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s6","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/services/search-engine-optimisation/seo-packages","supports":"Pricing page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/projects","supports":"Portfolio page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/projects/mackillop-family-services-case-study","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/contact","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s6","url":"https://spicyweb.com.au/services","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#spicy-web"},{"rank":3,"name":"Due North","score":62,"website":"https://duenorth.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":10},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s6","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/search-marketing-company/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/outcomes/cheaper-lead-costs/","supports":"Pricing page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/digital-marketing-case-studies/","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/contact-us/","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s6","url":"https://duenorth.com.au/digital-marketing-services/","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#due-north"},{"rank":4,"name":"Clickmatix Pty Ltd","score":59,"website":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au/who-we-are/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au/average-cost-of-seo-melbourne-businesses/","supports":"Pricing page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au/casestudies/","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://www.clickmatix.com.au/contact-us/","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#clickmatix-pty-ltd"},{"rank":4,"name":"Pixel3 Video Productions (Melbourne)","score":59,"website":"https://pixel3.com.au/","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":15},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://pixel3.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://pixel3.com.au/about-pixel3-productions/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://pixel3.com.au/knowledge/how-much-does-video-editing-cost-in-australia/","supports":"Pricing page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://pixel3.com.au/case-study-videos/","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://pixel3.com.au/video-production-contact-us/","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#pixel3-video-productions-melbourne"},{"rank":6,"name":"SIXGUN","score":52.5,"website":"https://sixgun.com.au/","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":18.5},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":7},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":10},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":1.5,"status":"partial","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://sixgun.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://sixgun.com.au/about/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://sixgun.com.au/team/","supports":"Team page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://sixgun.com.au/contact/","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#sixgun"},{"rank":7,"name":"Digital Treasury","score":52,"website":"https://digitaltreasury.com.au/","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":0},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.digitaltreasury.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.digitaltreasury.com.au/about-us","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://www.digitaltreasury.com.au/portfolio","supports":"Portfolio page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://www.digitaltreasury.com.au/contact-us","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://www.digitaltreasury.com.au/all-services","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#digital-treasury"},{"rank":8,"name":"Shout Digital","score":46,"website":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":7},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":0}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":7,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au/about-us/","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au/case-study/","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au/contact/","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://www.shoutdigital.com.au/services/","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#shout-digital"},{"rank":9,"name":"Clearwater Agency","score":44,"website":"https://clearwateragency.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":20},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":0},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":12},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":5}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":5,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://clearwateragency.com.au/","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://clearwateragency.com.au/about","supports":"About page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://clearwateragency.com.au/case-studies","supports":"Case studies","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://clearwateragency.com.au/contact","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://clearwateragency.com.au/ai-seo-agency/aeo-services","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#clearwater-agency"},{"rank":10,"name":"Appello Software","score":34,"website":"http://www.appello.com.au","notRankedReason":null,"checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":13},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":0},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":14},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":7},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":0}],"criteria":{"info":[{"key":"https","label":"Secure website (HTTPS)","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"about","label":"About page published","max":4,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"team","label":"Team or founders named","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s2","note":""},{"key":"services","label":"Service list published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s5","note":""},{"key":"address","label":"Physical address published","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"phone","label":"Phone or email published","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""}],"pricing":[{"key":"pricing_page","label":"Pricing or packages page","max":8,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"price_figure","label":"At least one price published","max":7,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"proof":[{"key":"portfolio","label":"Portfolio or work page","max":8,"points":8,"status":"yes","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"cases","label":"Case studies with results","max":6,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s3","note":""},{"key":"clients","label":"Named clients or testimonials","max":6,"points":6,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"reputation":[{"key":"google_rating","label":"Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"google_volume","label":"Google review volume","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"},{"key":"review_recency","label":"Recent reviews (last 12 months)","max":5,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet collected in this pilot"}],"contact":[{"key":"contact_page","label":"Contact page or form","max":4,"points":4,"status":"yes","evidence":"s4","note":""},{"key":"english","label":"English-language website","max":3,"points":3,"status":"yes","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"chat","label":"Instant channel (WhatsApp / chat)","max":3,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""}],"visibility":[{"key":"schema","label":"Organization structured data on website","max":5,"points":0,"status":"no","evidence":"s1","note":""},{"key":"ai_mentions","label":"Named by AI assistants for local queries","max":10,"points":0,"status":"unknown","evidence":null,"note":"Not yet measured in this pilot"}]},"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://appello.com.au","supports":"Homepage","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://appello.com.au/team","supports":"Team page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://appello.com.au/services/industry-social-networking","supports":"Portfolio page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s4","url":"https://appello.com.au/contact","supports":"Contact page","accessed":"2026-10-14"},{"id":"s5","url":"https://appello.com.au/services","supports":"Services page","accessed":"2026-10-14"}],"unverified":["Google rating (Bayesian-adjusted)","Google review volume","Recent reviews (last 12 months)","Named by AI assistants for local queries"],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#appello-software"},{"rank":null,"name":"Intentional","score":null,"website":"https://intention.al/how-to-choose-a-digital-ad-agency/","notRankedReason":"Website returned a server error on 2026-10-14","checked":"2026-10-14","categories":[{"key":"info","name":"Information transparency","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"pricing","name":"Price transparency","max":15,"points":0},{"key":"proof","name":"Portfolio & proof of work","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"reputation","name":"Public reputation","max":20,"points":0},{"key":"contact","name":"Communication & accessibility","max":10,"points":0},{"key":"visibility","name":"Digital & AI visibility","max":15,"points":0}],"criteria":{"info":[],"pricing":[],"proof":[],"reputation":[],"contact":[],"visibility":[]},"sources":[],"unverified":[],"url":"https://www.edvido.com/digital-marketing-agencies/melbourne#intentional"}]}